Should New Zealand decriminalize prostitution or not
Should New Zealand decriminalize prostitution or not? From the early centuries to now, prostitution is always a big issue world wide. Recently, prostitutes are attempting to alter the traditional definition as public sex as a degradation to various interpretations of prostitution as “sex industry” and the prostitutes as “sex workers”, requiring public recognition and standard worker benefits. It is still illegal in many countries and a topic cannot be disclosed in public (only underground) and not because people in those countries are stubborn or out of dated. No matter how much economic benefits those people can get from this “illegal industry”, it is still a “social crisis” embracing concepts of high- risk and harm. There are a variety of facts which convinced me that if New Zealand adopt the “prostitution reform bill”, it would be a backward step for women in this country. While all prostitutes are not women, the majority are.Legalization of prostitution lets prostitution expands. If the bill is passed the new law will assume that men’s prostitution behavior is inevitable (Jeffreys, 2003:3) and it is acceptable for men to buy and sell women’s sexual services. As a result, it will lead to treating wom
en as sexual commodies. In David’s book An international handbook on trends, problems and policies, he pointed out that “prostitutes are not unique in viewing their bodies as salable, standard courtship rules may require women to present themselves as objects ‘for sale’” (2), and ensure an adequate future income- a man who can pay a good price. We must admit that prostitution has a very high commercial value, and this results from it being illegal. Ordinary people cannot get into it. If it is legalized, more and more ordinary women will start to practice prostitution in order to get a high payment and if this becomes a reality, the prostitution reform bill has the kind of ill effects. Legalized prostitution let this reality become more realistic and cruel. If parliament passes the prostitution reform bill, New Zealand will be adopting a legislative model that has not only failed to achieve its objectives in Australia, it has given clients more power, made prostitutes more vulnerable and has lead to growth in the industry of prostitution. (Jeffreys, 2003: 10) Last but not least, I believed that legalization of prostitution does not enhance prostitutes’ choices. I agree that the enormous number of prostitutes who enter prostitution without being coerced into it by a third party do so for economic reasons, Nevertheless, there are still vast majority of those felt they had no other options. (ibid). It is fairly irresponsible to reduce the issue to “for and against”. When Melissa Farley (2003) interviewed 46 prostitutes aged betwee
Some topics in this essay:
,
Tim Barnett‘s,
Sheila Jeffreys,
Auckland Wellington,
Melissa Farley,
prostitution reform,
prostitution reform bill,
reform bill,
prostitution reform law,
reform law,
legalization prostitution,
farley 2003,
protect prostitutes,
view prostitution,
prostitution farley 2003,
bill protect,
prostitutes transmitted diseases,
prostitution farley,
prostitutes transmitted,
protect prostitutes transmitted,
Join now to see the rest of the essay!
Approximate Word count = 1047
Approximate Pages = 4 (250 words per page double spaced)
|
Example Essays Home
