When answering to Ivan’s challenge, first I must put myself in Alyosha’s position. Since Alyosha is a devout Christian, he should understand that every Christian should act and think according to the holy bible. There are three reasons that can help Alyosha decide whether or not to create this fabric of human destiny with the ultimate goal to make men happy in the end, even though it means to torture to death one tiny creature: following the path of Christianity, consideration of free will, and the ultimatum of faith.

By following the path of Christianity, an obvious example comes to the mind. Alyosha, as a Christian, should think of the story of Jesus Christ, God’s own son. God send his own son Jesus to Earth in a human form to save the whole world but it was essential to torture him and crucified him till death at the end. This scenario is very similar to the one that Ivan gave to Alyosha. God did it with his own son for the sake of the rest of mankind. What looks like immoral and wrong in common sense, does not necessary mean it is wrong in the bible. The cause of this sacrifice serves a great purpose. Our goal is not the life we valued now but it’s the li

In conclusion, having carefully analyzed Ivan’s challenge, the conclusion I would draw from my analysis is that Alyosha should accept this challenge because he is a Christian. Free will problem is just a matter of how he manipulates it and if understood correctly, he can make a better statement against his brother saying that everyone has a will to choose, whether you noticed or not. The example of Jesus shows that following the path of Christianity is also a helpful way to answer to the challenge because Jesus, God’s own son did the same. Ultimately it’s all about the faith we have in our religion and he as a devoted one should not be afraid to answer the confrontation set by his brother Ivan.

Also, we should consider free will when analyzing Ivan’s challenge. The matter of free will has always been very complicated and continues to be a big issue when discussing about religion. In Ivan’s challenge, the tiny creature should be given the choice to choose whether to sacrifice itself or not. Obviously when common sense is applied, the creature would choose not to die and the challenge ends. As previously mentioned though, common sense can’t be always relied on, especially when talking about religion. According to Christianity, the free will here shouldn’t be to choice between sacrificing or not, but more to believing in God or not. If the creature believes in God, he should accept his faith, provide aid to all mankind, and join God in heaven for the life

Some topics in this essay:
God” Faith, Alyosha God, God God, Alyosha Ivan, Brothers Karamazov”, According Christianity, Christian Free, Jesus God’s, Ivan Finally, Jesus Earth, ivan’s challenge, common sense, own son, life death, tiny creature, path christianity, god’s own son, choose sacrifice, challenge conclusion, god shouldn’t, christian choose, ivan’s challenge conclusion, accept ivan’s challenge,