Women in the Combat
The question of whether women should be given the right to serve in a combat position is one that has been left unanswered. Direct combat roles have always been closed to women. However, many supporters have believed in the past that with the proper training, women could be turned into military machines. On the other hand, opposers have said that women have not possessed the ability and strength to be launched into a hand to hand combat situation. A large number of studies have concluded that women simply have not the skills and physicality that have been needed in combat positions. Overall, hand to hand combat roles should be left to primarily men or any woman who has passed the same rigorous physical tests that men are held to. “Combat is not primarily about brains, or patriotism, or dedication to duty (Catherine L. Aspy).” There has been no question raised over whether or not women have had the same intelligence level as men. Women generally outscore or score as high as men on written tests (Komarow). However, combat situations, in most cases, have called for physical strength, which has bee
The strength factor has been apparent when it has came to comparing the average male solider to the average female solider. The United States Navy studied the upper body strength in 38 men and women. Overall, it was discovered that in many cases women had approximately only half of the lifting power of men. Another United States Navy study reported that the top seven percent of women out of 239 had the equivalent upper body strength as the bottom seven percent of men. Approximately 46 women in an Army study were given a 24-week training session that was supposedly supposed to improve their lifting abilities. Even though some of these women’s abilities were improved, they still could not compare to their male counterparts. It has also been shown that “women have a smaller heart mass, heart volume and cardiac output than men (Catherine L. Aspy).” The rate at which the heart, lungs, and blood vessels can move oxygen to muscles is directly related to one’s physical performance. Overall, the female solider has been 4.7 inches shorter, 33.9 pounds lighter, and she has had 37.8 less lean body mass. Lean body mass has be
Some topics in this essay:
Women Combat,
Overall American,
Catherine Aspy”,
United Navy,
Catherine Aspy,
USS Tortuga,
Komarow Women,
Komarow” Overall,
combat roles,
Michelle Howard,
catherine aspy,
hand hand,
related one’s physical,
lean body mass,
hand combat,
combat positions,
written tests,
seven percent,
written tests komarow,
male counterparts,
upper body strength,
tests komarow,
hand hand combat,
catherine aspy”,
Join now to see the rest of the essay!
Approximate Word count = 765
Approximate Pages = 3 (250 words per page double spaced)
More Essays on Women in the Combat Professional Papers: |
CUSTOMER SERVICES
|
|
Saved Papers
You haven't saved any papers.
|