Too Close to the Bone
In “Too Close to the Bone: The Historical Context for Women’s Obsession with Slenderness” the author Roberta Seid talks about how American women are obsessed with maintaining an “ideal” weight. She wrote this essay while working as a lecturer in the Program for the Study of Women and Men at USC. In this essay, she provides historical backgrounds on weight loss, and discusses where the image of an “ideal” weight came from. She then leads into a section that tells about women and weight loss compared to men and weight loss. She ends the selection with solutions she has for the problem. I intend to summarize the article, show that the reasoning she uses is not always sound, and I will also point out some weak spots in the article. Women in the world have become “fatphobic” that is, they are becoming obsessed with ridding their bodies of fat. One explanation for the obsession is the role fashion has played in weight regulation. However, it does not explain the millions of women with clinical eating disorders, or explain why eating disorders have bloomed into social diseases. The best explanation is that we have allowed the pursuit of a lean, fat-free body bloom into a religion. Achieving thinness has not al
The author was a lecturer at the University of Southern California when this she wrote this essay, so the information she relays is more than likely accurate. For the most part, the information she relates is significant, however, I do not feel that the information regarding the centuries before ours were necessary. Seid does a fine job of defining terms that need defining. However, the author fails to provide any statistics to back up her claims. Some people will not believe something if there are no numbers to back up the claim. The lack of statistics makes the paper seem too opinionated. There are also plenty of statistics to refute her claim. The rate of obesity in America has increased greatly, and while there are plenty of people in our country with weight loss problems, there are also a great number of people without them. The historical background seems accurate, but it is not relevant to the paper. The author also spends too much time discussing the history of weight regulation. In conclusion, the author does a fine job of achieving her goals of showing how weight loss is a problem in America. She uses historical background to show the evolution of the “religion of thinness”. She has no hard evidence to back up her claims, and this weakens the paper, but she proposes ve
Some topics in this essay:
Women USC,
Southern California,
Roberta Seid,
weight loss,
Obsession Slenderness”,
weight loss america,
,
wrote essay,
“ideal” weight,
eating disorders,
historical background,
weight regulation,
loss america,
fine job,
Join now to see the rest of the essay!
Approximate Word count = 879
Approximate Pages = 4 (250 words per page double spaced)
More Essays on Too Close to the Bone Professional Papers: |
CUSTOMER SERVICES
|
|
Saved Papers
You haven't saved any papers.
|