Henry V Film Comparison
After viewing two different versions of Shakespeare’s Henry V, the audience may have two very different opinions of Henry as a King. On one hand he must be applauded for the incredible victory over France even against such great odds. On the other hand many may see him as unprepared for his duties, and as a heartless man who doesn’t care about the lives of his people. This of course is not true, and his soldiers begin to see this after he delivers his famous “band of brothers” speech. Overall, the directors paint different pictures of Henry. Sir Olivier chose to give the film a more lighthearted approach and include some comedy in the film. Kenneth Branagh on the other hand chose to portray Henry’s serious determined nature. The differences can be clearly seen in many scenes, but very early in both films, the tone is set. When the dauphin chooses to send the king a gift and a message, the king’s reply shows the different interpretations of Henry’s character from each director. This one scene sets up the play’s understanding for the audience. In Sir Lawrence Olivier’s version of the play, the scene is played out like a play within a film. The colors are very bright and cheerful and the s
In Branagh’s film, we see a much different side of Henry. We see a king who means business. He is angry at the message and the insulting gift, yet conveys his anger in a manner that is controlled and non-violent. He wants France to know that in the past they may have doubted him due to his wild and unruly youth, but now he has grown into a man who will claim what is his, and who is willing to fight for his crown and country. Branagh shows Henry as a less friendly king, yet a man who possesses loyalty to his duties and his country. He is a king who is willing to take what is rightfully England’s even at the cost of shed blood. In Olivier’s version it is hard to see Henry as a serious threat, but here Branagh shows that he is very serious about his claims. This helps us understand the rest of the play because we see that the French are seriously naïve when it comes to the carelessness they chose to take England’s threats. They leave Harfleur unprotected and even after its defeat they still do not understand that Henry will stop at nothing for the crown. Branagh’s version of the film is simply more believable than Olivier’s film. If the audience had not read Henry V before and saw Olivier’s version first, then they too might laugh at the King and his threats. Branagh’s version on the other hand, conveys the seriousness of the situation and shows the audience that the King can be taken seriously and that he has turned from the errs of his youth. In Kenneth Branagh’s version of the film, we see a much different King Henry. The scene itself is much darker and very realistic, far from a staged scene. As Montjoy the
Some topics in this essay:
Branagh Henry,
Henry Olivier,
Lawrence Olivier’s,
Dauphin Henry,
Kenneth Branagh,
Henry King,
Kings Shakespeare’s,
Henry Olivier’s,
King Henry,
Sir Olivier,
olivier version,
branagh’s version,
olivier’s version,
henry king,
tosses crown,
brothers counsel,
version film,
branagh henry,
branagh’s version film,
crown france,
Join now to see the rest of the essay!
Approximate Word count = 1105
Approximate Pages = 4 (250 words per page double spaced)
More Essays on Henry V Film Comparison Professional Papers: |
Join Now
(Credit Card)
|
Join Now
(Online Check)
|
Join Now
(Phone 1-900)
|
CUSTOMER SERVICES
| |
|