Comparison of Sands of Iwo Jima and Saving Private Ryan
By examining two movies, The Sands of Iwo Jima (1949) and Saving Private Ryan (1998), many similarities and differences can be found which can be linked to greater generalizations and concepts. Neglecting all differences in time period, perception, character depth, and special effects, these movies essentially are the same. They portray similar ideas of camaraderie, difficulties of war, intimate relationships, and importance of command. With the addition of technology and more realistic techniques in acting, Saving Private Ryan had the ability to go into more depth with every emotion that the audience felt. In contrast, The Sands of Iwo Jima missed out on many of the realities of war, but still inspired limited emotion in its audience. This difference is mainly caused by the development of setting and tone by the film’s creators. From the initial scene sequence, the creators of Saving Private Ryan set a tone of intense realism, which was to continue throughout the movie. While storming the Omaha Beach, scenes of decapitation, crying, vomiting, bleeding, and dying brought the viewer to a realization that war was no picnic. It could be grasped why a soldier’s life would be forever changed by such an experience. Also, additions
Through intricate plots and in-depth character development, the filmmakers are trying to send a specific message to their audiences. These generalizations are difficult to make for the audience, who is simply absorbing the content released by these filmmakers. But, I believe that the makers of both Saving Private Ryan and The Sands of Iwo Jima had one common theme in mind. Over all of the personal stories and conflicts, both of these men wanted to glorify and idealize the participants in the battles of World War II. Although the success of these attempts are both debatable, the pursuit if this goal cannot be doubted. World War II is a large part of our national past time, and our success in it was vital to the security of the world. We truly do not show our veterans enough gratitude, and these movies try to turn our attention to a major event that can be overlooked. The main message sent by these two movies is to honor the heroes that truly matter. In The Sands of Iwo Jima, I believe that the filmmakers sought the same realism and emotional ups and downs that Saving Private Ryan created, but lacked the ability. Much like the other film, all of the soldiers come from different backgrounds and different points of view. This was highlighted by Conway’s repulsion of Stryder because he reminds him of his perfectionist father. Despite this, all are forced to work together to achieve one common goal. The Sands of Iwo Jima also brings a comical and fun aspect to its plot, but completely disconnects it from the scenes of battle. The soldiers go on leave in New Zealand to meet girls and drink, which is totally unrelated to harshness and realisms of actual war. But, this movie also brings a romantic side to the war, highlighted by Allison and Conway. like a running camera
Some topics in this essay:
Private Ryan,
Germans Americans,
Iwo Jima,
John Miller,
Sergeant Horvath,
Omaha Beach,
War II,
private ryan,
saving private,
Saving Private,
saving private ryan,
Pvt Ryan’s,
Captain Miller,
iwo jima,
sands iwo jima,
sands iwo,
world war ii,
war ii,
special effects,
emotion audience,
world war,
main characters,
Join now to see the rest of the essay!
Approximate Word count = 1201
Approximate Pages = 5 (250 words per page double spaced)
|
Example Essays Home
