Example Essays Home
FAQ
Acceptable Use Policy
Tech Support
LOG IN!
Click HERE for Instant Access
 
This is a free preview of the paper.
Join Now
Log In
  

To what extent is it morally wrong to continue using the med

In the second half of World War 2 the Nazi scientists performed brutal medical experiments upon helpless concentration camp inmates as a form of torture. Much of the information, which was obtained from these experiments, is still relevant in studies, however it is constantly debated whether it is morally justifiable to use this knowledge to benefit the people of today.

The inmates were forced to become subjects in very dangerous studies against their will and almost all were subjected to incredible suffering, mutilation, and indescribable pain. The experiments often were deliberately designed to have a fatal outcome for their victims. Hitler's regime sponsored a series of inhumane experiments for alleged ideological, military and medical purposes. The Nazi doctors considered "military necessity" adequate justification for their horrific experiments. They justified their acts by saying that the prisoners were condemned to death anyway.

One experiment consisted of prisoners being immersed into tanks of ice water for hours at a time, often shivering to death, to discover how long German pilots downed by enemy fire could survive the frozen waters of the North Sea.

In 1942, hazardous high-altitude experiments began to determ


Recently, there has been a dispute regarding the scientific validity of the experiments and whether data gathered from lethal experiments on unwilling subjects could be used in any way by the scientific community. It is doubtful that physiological responses of the tortured and maimed victims represents the responses of the people for whom the experiments were meant to benefit. The fact that the Nazi experiments were never officially published or replicated raises doubts about the data's scientific accuracy. Also we must remember to consider the scientific and medical competence of the Nazi doctors when discussing the validity of their knowledge. Ultimately, the arguments as to whether the experiments were scientific or not, or whether the doctors were medically competent or not, leaves one with the impression that had such experiments been "good" science and the doctors medical professionals, these facts would somehow change our impression of the doctors and their experiments. This is not true as the sadistic evil, which was performed by Nazis in concentration camps, is in no way lessened by its scientific value.

The argument of whether it is morally wrong to use the information which was obtained from the Nazi experiments is still relevant to today as research is still needed for medical reasons. After reviewing the graphic descriptions of how the Nazis conducted the experiments, it has become increasingly difficult to remain objective and unbiased when analysing whether it is right or wrong to use the knowledge gained from the experiments. In our opinion it is wrong for scientists to use the information gained from the horrific experiments to find purpose in the victims' deaths, as this would suggest that what the Nazi scientists did was not entirely wrong. However we do believe that if the information will help to save lives then using it should not be objected to as it is human instinct to want to save lives, and the knowledge can then by of some benefit to future generations.

It could be said that the American’s behaviour concerning operation paperclip was based on the principles of egoism. Egoists believe that you should do what you can to promote your interests, even if this means destroying the interests of others. The USA wanted the information from the experiments so that it wouldn’t fall into the hands of the Soviet Union

Some topics in this essay:
Harry Truman, Kristine Moe, Soviet Union, World War, Joseph Mengele, Russian American, North Sea, Jews Thousands, TB Live, nazi scientists, save lives, nazi experiments, war crimes, punishment war crimes, punishment war, knowledge benefit, information gained, aryan race, , using information gained, germany military, conducted experiments, escaped punishment war, save lives knowledge, instinct save lives,

Join now to see the rest of the essay!
Approximate Word count = 1595
Approximate Pages = 6 (250 words per page double spaced)


  

Join Now
(Credit Card)
Join Now
(Online Check)
Join Now
(Phone 1-900)



CUSTOMER SERVICES




Acceptance Essays
Arts
Custom Essays
English
Foreign
History
Miscellaneous
Movies
Music
Novels
People
Politics
Religion
Science
Sports
Technology
Book Notes

 

 


All papers are for research and references purposes only!
Copyright © 2002-2009 ExampleEssays.com DMCA
Saved Papers