Example Essays Home
FAQ
Acceptable Use Policy
Tech Support
LOG IN!
Click HERE for Instant Access
 
This is a free preview of the paper.
Join Now
Log In
  

Literacy Does Not Erase Orality

In his article “Caught in a net of words” (2000), McKenzie Wark examines the fate of Aboriginal culture in a society where it seemingly must adopt European forms of writing in order to exist. A theme prevalent in the article is that while writing is an important and necessary tool of communication in Western society, for Aboriginal people, writing has been a historical enemy. He maintains that it has been an instrument of Colonial oppression, and that when Aboriginal people are forced to adopt European forms of writing in order to communicate, their culture is subordinated in Australian society. While he admits that Aboriginals have successfully adopted writing as a means of communication, he asserts that by doing so, they are erasing the inherent orality of their culture. As a whole, Wark’s argument seems to be not without merit. Writing has indeed been utilised as a means to administer and control the lives of Aboriginal people in the past, and to an extent, still is to this day. It is also the case that in order to exist and have a chance to survive in a predominately Western society, Aboriginal culture seems to have little choice but to adopt numerous Western societal attributes. However, to say that adopting writing as


Taking the above definitions into consideration, a number of inferences can be drawn about the nature of cultures. Firstly, it could be argued that cultural values and practices are a direct product of the environment in which a particular society exists. Secondly, as stated in the first definition, cultures exist in relation to time, and therefore can be perceived as dynamic by nature; as the environment changes with time, so too will the society and cultures within that environment. All this considered, it would seem that changes to a culture occur only as a result of changes to the environment over a given period of time, and those changes undertaken are necessary for the culture to successfully adapt to that environment. It would also seem reasonable to assume, that any given facet of a culture not explicitly affected by a change of environment, will remain unchanged until required by the environment to do so. Assuming the above to be true, it seems difficult to argue that any change caused to Aboriginal culture as a whole by the adaptation of European forms of literacy can be detrimental. The change in itself is necessary to adapt to the new environment presented by the invasion of Australia by the British. Without in any way trying to argue that the taking over of Aboriginal lands was justifiable or moral, the change to the Australian environment has irrevocably occurred, and therefore, for Aboriginal society not to adapt somewhat to Western ways would surely be a negative outcome.

Let us now consider the idea of Aboriginal culture being one of orality. Saying that Aboriginal culture is an oral culture seems to imply that their interaction as a society is restricted to speaking. It is generally well known that oral communication has been, and still is a very important means by which Aboriginal people interact, and pass on their cultural heritage and ideals to younger generations. It is also true that before adopting phonographic script from Europeans, Aboriginals had no way to directly express their languages other than verbally. But to say that speech was the only form of communication used by Aborigines before the arrival of Europeans before the arrival of Europeans is simple untrue. Phonographic script is by no means the only non-verbal medium of communication that has been used by humans throughout history. Other abundant forms of written communication include pictographs and ideographs (lecture 11th March, 2004). A pictograph can be defined as any picture or symbol representing a word, idea, or numerical figure (http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=pictograph). An ideograph is also a pictorial form of expression, representing an idea or object, but without expressing the pronunciation of a particular word; as would phonographic script (http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=ideogram). Aboriginals were using pictographs and ideographs to convey information long before any foreigners set foot on Australian shores. They have carved and painted

Some topics in this essay:
McKenzie Wark, Europeans Aboriginals, Jackie Huggins, Langford Ginibi, Australia British, Saying Aboriginal, aboriginal people, Aboriginal Reserve, aboriginal culture, , Rita Huggins, phonographic script, Huggins Huggins, australian society, european forms, pictographs ideographs, oral culture, aboriginal culture oral, means communication, culture oral, affected change, culture oral culture, lives aboriginal people, adopt european forms, european forms literacy,

Join now to see the rest of the essay!
Approximate Word count = 2009
Approximate Pages = 8 (250 words per page double spaced)


  

Join Now
(Credit Card)
Join Now
(Online Check)
Join Now
(Phone 1-900)



CUSTOMER SERVICES




Acceptance Essays
Arts
Custom Essays
English
Foreign
History
Miscellaneous
Movies
Music
Novels
People
Politics
Religion
Science
Sports
Technology
Book Notes

 

 


All papers are for research and references purposes only!
Copyright © 2002-2009 ExampleEssays.com DMCA
Saved Papers