Type a new keyword(s) and press Enter to search

Close reading canterbury tales

 

             Overriding friendship, law, and even blood, Love prevails above all else. The aforementioned resonates as the principal theme throughout Arcite's reply to Palamon in "The Knight's Tale." To begin proving his point to Palamon, Arcite recalls the old saying, "'All's fair in love,'" conveying that love conquers all, and actions and crimes committed in the act of love are fair. Arcite then continues to elaborate upon his explanation as he states that "love is a greater law / than any other that may be given to any earthly man" (307-308). This places love on a pedestal above all other things known to man. Love is placed before any law, any friendship, and any blood, no matter the circumstances. Arcite continues to describe the decree to which love overrides such laws, and as he does so, he also reminds Palamon that they will never "be in her grace," (315) so their argument with each other about this matter of love with Emily, is pointless. In relating to the bigger picture of "The Knight's Tale" as a whole, Arcite and Palamon both, as Arcite states, do not have a chance with this woman of their dreams. Chaucer utilizes the following simile to emphasize this concept: "We vie like dogs fighting for the bone: / they fought all day, and yet had no part of it; / while they were raging, a kite came / and bore off the bone from between the two of them." (319-322). Chaucer likens Arcite and Palamon to dogs, and Emily, their love, to a bone. This simile accentuates the irrationality of their argument. Since they will remain in prison, Emily will not even realize either's love; a man will eventually come along and, like the kite, will take Emily, the bone, right from under their noses. Arcite ends the passage by telling Palamon, that he cannot stop him from loving her, and he knows he cannot stop Palamon from loving her as well; however, each must fight for himself. This significantly ties the passage together as it contains the main theme that love prevails above all, yet it also shows through the advice Arcite gives that although he loves Palamon as a brother, he would take his chance with Emily if he had one which forshadows what is yet to come.


Essays Related to Close reading canterbury tales