This testis basically stating a person is insane if he or she is not capable of distinguishing between right and wrong. The Irresistible Impulse test states that a person is unable to control his or her actions, but is able to distinguish between right and wrong. The two tests are usually combined to determine the mental abilities of the criminal. The Irresistible Impulse test suggests that a person may have an integrated personality and is rarely seen in the commission of a major crime. One criticism of this test is the difficulty, for the jury, of deciding whether the impulse was irresistible or simply un-resisted. The Durham Rule may also be used, suggesting that insanity represent many personality factors, all of which may not be presented in every case. The Durham rule states that the accused is not criminally responsible if the unlawful act was the product of mental disease or be able to define mental disease or defect.
.
When the insanity defense is implanted in a trial the legal definition will almost always vary, depending on which rule the lawyer wants to adopt. Both the defense and the prosecution will have their own psychiatrists trying to prove their case. In the end the jury will have to decide which side was the most believable. How is it possible for the jury to decide whether or not the defendant is sane or insane? Professionals do not even agree on the meaning of mental illness. The jury will have to take the testimony that has been manipulated by lawyers and make their own conclusion.
.
There is no neat or generally accepted definition of insanity, but the dictionary defines insanity as "persistent mental disorder or derangement" under Law it is defined as "unsoundness of mind sufficient in the judgement of a civil court to render a person unfit to maintain a contractual or other legal relationship or to warrant commitment to a mental health facility" or "In most criminal jurisdictions, a degree of mental malfunctioning sufficient to relieve the accused of legal responsibility for the act committed".
