Book IX in The Republic by Plato is mainly an argument to prove justice is better than injustice. Throughout the first part of Book IX, Socrates speaks about tyranny and the tyrannical man. Socrates proves that a tyrannical man (unjust ... lives and therefore an aristocrat, being the just man, leads the happiest of lives. This is the first example that proves justice is better than injustice in Book IX. In the second part of Book IX, The Republic, Socrates provides a second argument for the conclusion that life is better as a just man than as an unjust man. ... the better of him. Therefore, th...

• Word Count: 877
• Approx Pages: 4
• Grade Level: High School

The statement "Family values teach us many wonderful things -- but justice is not one of them," seems to follow very closely with the opinion of Plato in his Republic. He maintains that the teaches unity which, when applied on a grand scale, can lead to justice but that the unity of private families will only lead to unjust favoring of one's kin and to factionalism that ... is inherently unjust.  From this, Plato develops a plan in which he establishes a communal family for ... amongst family members, without the injustice it creates.  However, from this course of action it appears only tw...

• Word Count: 574
• Approx Pages: 2
• Grade Level: High School

Webster's Dictionary defines justice as the quality of being just; conformity to the principles of righteousness and rectitude in all things; strict performance of moral obligations; practical conformity to human or divine law; integrity in the dealings of men with each other; rectitude; equity; uprightness. Thrasymachus's views justice as an advantage of the stronger. The example he gives I that the government makes up laws to help itself and declares just for their people. This proves Thrasymuchus's point in that justice benefits other people while injustice benefits you. In modern day we c...

• Word Count: 335
• Approx Pages: 1
• Grade Level: High School

... (the just man who appears unjust) does live well. In the process Socrates must also supply a positive definition of justice that will resist scrutiny. You might want to notice that here, among other things, we are getting our first major hint that the Republic, is an expanded and revised version of the Apology. Socrates himself is exactly such a man: one who is ... again. The problem being posed is a very tall order, and you should remember that the rest of the Republic is a detour and device to answer this question, as well as Thrasymachus" position. Plato will answer this question by ...

• Word Count: 1028
• Approx Pages: 4

Through the reading of Plato's Republic and Hume's An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals the reader can see many conflicts in ideas such as the idea between Thrasymachus and Hume on Justice. Thrasymachus believes that justice is simply the advantage of the stronger, ruling class. (Plato 14) Hume on the other hand believes that justice is significant for its usefulness. For example, if there were a society ... class be given an excess of the things they need. This would leave little or none for the lesser people so the justice is not useful to them. (Plato 15) On the other hand if Hum...

• Word Count: 477
• Approx Pages: 2
• Grade Level: High School

... in an unjust fashion, but his tracks are cleared and that is all that matters to him. This is a perfect example of someone who seems just succeeding in life. In Plato's Republic, Glaucon speaks of this perfectly unjust man, who when set in opposition reigns over the just man. He speaks of how this perfectly unjust man will rule in the city ... the right decision. I feel that my conscience is too strong to allow me to seem just. I think that seeming just is just as bad as actually being unjust, therefore I choose justice....

• Word Count: 998
• Approx Pages: 4
• Grade Level: High School