1. The Identity of Law
... positivism or conventionalism. This discretion will lead to the new law applying retrospectively. Dworin is saying that there is some sort of moral standard pre-existing the rules which do not allow us to have a formalistic application of rules in hard cases. He says that these cases are decided through the ... application of standards – principles and policies. Hard cases are one in which the judges has to decide when there is no pre-existing rule exists that governs a situation or the application of the rule results in unsatisfactory results. He says Hart fails to explain the presenc...
- Word Count: 7680
- Approx Pages: 31
- Grade Level: High School