Who then is the .
enforcer, "him who performs"? It could either mean a police force commanded by the .
authority, or it could mean any person under the rule of the authority who obeys the law. .
I favour the latter interpretation. Police forces exist only in a state, and Montaigne's quote .
does not only refer to laws in a state. A general, for example, may order his troops to go .
into battle, and in this situation it is everyone under the general's authority who enforce .
the general's "law". I interpret "enforcer" to mean the people themselves. .
.
The word "impute" often has negative connotations, that of naming someone .
responsible for something that has gone wrong, but I would argue that Montaigne meant .
this word to be interpreted both negatively and positively, since good laws may also be .
"enforced by command". "Perform" should not be interpreted by its literal definition .
because many laws and commands are imposed to prevent actions from being performed. .
Rather, this should be interpreted to mean "to comply with". Now that the sentence has .
been so reduced, its meaning as I interpret it is: responsibility for any law (and whatever .
results from the enforcement of that law) is given more to the authority who sets down the .
law and commands obedience than to the people who follow its commands. .
.
This quote is a comment on the way in which people perceive not only the law, .
but history itself. The laws of a nation determine a large part of its history. It is not meant .
to say that the authority which created the law is responsible for it, but that responsibility .
for the law is attributed to the authority by the people, and this suggests to me that .
Montaigne considered this common perception to be false. This is indeed the way people .
today perceive both negative and positive historical events. For example, who do we .
usually blame today for the atrocities which occurred in Nazi Germany during WWII? In .