(855) 4-ESSAYS

Type a new keyword(s) and press Enter to search

Difference Between Libertarianists And Determinists

            In this paper I will examine the differences in the beliefs of libertarianists and determinists. A libertarianist believes that one can decide one's own fate, while a determinist believes that all of our actions are pre determined for us. I will explain why determinism has more of a scientific backbone than libertarianism and why the idea of every event having a cause behind it is more feasible. .
             I will show how these two sides will react to this specific question. If there is a machine that can predict what I will do in the immediate future, and it tells me that I am about to sit and write my philosophy paper, is it possible for me to do anything else? Am I able to deliberate my actions and throw causality to the wind?.
             Many would argue by nature that I could easily do something besides write the paper. The more popular belief is that people are in charge of their own futures and decisions and that is what people want to believe. Libertarians believe this and offer facts to persuade those unsure. In Elements of Philosophy the Libertarian view point is explained (283). Their two main theories are that we often deliberate over our decisions, considering alternative actions and thinking of possible consequences. .
             Another argument for free choice is our need to believe that people are morally responsible for their actions. Because of free choice, someone who commits a crime can be held morally responsible. If free choice does not apply, the applicable punishments would be unjust because the offender would have had no other alternatives. Someone who believes in free choice would argue that I am free not to write my paper regardless of what the machine predicts if I deliberate and consider the options in my head. But there are some who disagree.
             Determinists do not believe in free choice. They maintain that certain conditions cause the occurrence of every event (283). Thinking that one is free to choose is an illusion.


Essays Related to Difference Between Libertarianists And Determinists

1. The Concept of Free Will

The question has given rise to three main positions: determinist, compatibilist and libertarianism. ... Determinists argue that because of the laws of nature, everything happens according to these laws. ... As a result of this argument, determinists are inclined to argue that agents cannot be held accountable for moral actions as they do not have the choice to do otherwise. ... Libertarianists argue that agents are morally responsible for their actions as they have the freedom of choice of whether to perform a certain act or choose an alternative. ... For libertarianists, this exception is cha...

  • Word Count: 1943
  • Approx Pages: 8
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

2. Can Free Will And Determinism Co-exist

David Hume, as a determinist, believed that every event in the world is caused by some previous event, and that there is no randomness present in the universe. He also believed in the idea of free will, which is contradictory in that it goes against everything that he believed in as a determinist. ... As a determinist, Hume believed that God, as the first cause, initiated all future causes, and that all causes continue to initiate future causes. The contradiction between the ideas of determinists and those who believe in free will is apparent by simply comparing these definitions. ... Fo...

  • Word Count: 548
  • Approx Pages: 2
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

3. Hard Determinism

Q: How might a hard determinist justify punishment? ... A hard determinist believes that determinism is true, and that free will is an illusion. ... From the above explanations, it is easy to see how a hard determinist might think punishment makes no sense. ... A typical hard determinist would say no, they should not be punished. This seems to be the most reasonable answer, but punishment could also be argued in favor of by a hard determinist. ...

  • Word Count: 369
  • Approx Pages: 1

4. Hard Determinism

In the book, "The Metamorphosis", Gregor can be interpreted as being either a hard determinist, soft determinist, or a libertarian. From the reader's standpoint, Gregor resembles that of a hard determinist, one whose decisions are made by the relevant natural conditions under which they occur, because his selfish parents treat him as a continuously working robot that repeats the same tasks over and over again. ... Gregor doesn't display a character who's a soft determinist because he has no control over his choices or desires. ... In the story "Metamorphosis", Gregor is unable t...

  • Word Count: 361
  • Approx Pages: 1
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

5. Determinism

Also time is reversible according to determinists. ... In criticizing determinism, Prigogine says science is a form of communication between people and nature. Through time there has been intense fragmentation between field and humanities arose because of this and there is a split between science and human knowledge . Determinist see the world as a closed system in an unique order. ... We cannot think beings independently from time and space as determinists do. ...

  • Word Count: 1112
  • Approx Pages: 4

6. Free Will Vs. Determinism

Throughout history, the problem of free will vs. determinism has sparked major debates between philosophers. ... From a determinist point of view, if certain causes lead to certain results, then similar causes should always lead to similar results. ... According to the determinist view, a person's actions are completely predetermined. ... How does the determinist explain this? ... A determinist would still argue that the choices one makes are casually determined, as is one's life span. ...

  • Word Count: 1614
  • Approx Pages: 6
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: High School

7. Martians and Venutians

The differences between the sexes have long been debated in the scientific and social arenas. ... If we consider gender to be a cultural definition of the differences between men and women, it follows that as our culture changes, so do these definitions. ... Today, sexual-biological differences between men and women grow less and less apparent. ... Nevertheless, it seems to me that it would be much easier to redefine cultural behavior rather than nature, by accepting the differences between men and women. ... Yet there still exist differences between men and women, that are based on our cultur...

  • Word Count: 1269
  • Approx Pages: 5

8. The Power of Free Will and of Things Already Determined

Blatchford is a hard determinist who argues that it is not possible to poses free will. Stance is a soft determinist who believes that we poses free will to a certain degree. Taylor is a self-determinist who believes that humans have free will. ... When a man must choose between heredity and environment he must one would say he must choose between desire and conscious. ... But according to self- determinists that is false. ...

  • Word Count: 2386
  • Approx Pages: 10
  • Grade Level: High School

9. Engels

Therefore, this piece is an interpretation of Marx's writing, and develops the idea that Marx was a "strict economic determinist," and that Marxism was a scientific account of historical inevitability. ...

  • Word Count: 522
  • Approx Pages: 2
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

Got a writing question? Ask our professional writer!
Submit My Question