(855) 4-ESSAYS

Type a new keyword(s) and press Enter to search

Effectiveness of the jury system

            
             The jury system has existed for almost 800 years. It was first introduced into England to replace the old system of trial by physical ordeal. Over the years the system of trial by jury has changed considerably. Through this court system, criminal law is interpreted by a jury who are seen as expressing the opinion and sense of the ordinary man and woman in society. The punishment however is awarded by a judge who is trained in sentencing, so that there is some consistency in the punishment to fit the crime.
             In Australia the jury is made up of 12 people, however the amount of people in a jury can vary depending on which sate or country the trial is taking place in, eg in the United States of America criminal cases are tried by six member juries. .
             During this essay I will discuss the positive and negative consequences of using the jury system in Australia and explore some of the solutions which have been suggested to replace the problems and unhappiness arising from perceived injustices. .
             Some of the positive attributes that a Jury brings to a trial are that the law is given a human face and cases are not always black and white. A judge is compelled to apply the law in a strict and technical way. Whereas a jury is able to base their verdict on the fairness of a case and are able to bring in different elements such as empathy for the plaintiff and the general feeling of the community towards the crime. .
             The Jury also brings in a wide diversity of opinions as every individual has their own beliefs and theories and because of this it is more likely that the overall result will be more accurate. .
             The use of a jury made up of citizens drawn from the community also ensures that the legal system doesn't become distant, nor alien to, the public. The use of the jury therefore keeps the criminal justice system on level with the standards of ordinary, everyday people this also ensures that the support of the community behind the legal justice system is maintained.


Essays Related to Effectiveness of the jury system

1. Effectiveness of the Jury System

The system of trial by jury has changed considerably since it was first introduced into 13th century England to replace the old system of trial by physical ordeal. ... The system lets the peers decide on what they think is right. ... A jury operates in a similar way, except with twelve minds rather than one. ... So if one day they do decide that the jury system is inadequate it is not as though the court system will be in trouble. It is really up to personal opinion whether or not the jury system works. ...

  • Word Count: 446
  • Approx Pages: 2
  • Grade Level: High School

2. On the adversarial system

Critically evaluate the adversarial system and to indicate whether any improvements, based on alternative systems, can be implemented in order to enhance the effectiveness of our court system. The Australian Court System is based upon the adversarial system. ... This is caused by the etiquette of the system as parties are allowed to control their arguments by presenting only evidence beneficial to their case to the jury and the judge. Similarly the encouragement of unfair litigation tactics can possibly sway the judge and the jury from the truth. ... In conclusion it can be seen the adversa...

  • Word Count: 594
  • Approx Pages: 2
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

3. The Preamble and Govermental Effectiveness

Doe, a student would deliver a prayer over the school's public address system prior to every varsity home football game. ... Under this ruling, students may pray individually or in groups but not over the public address system. ... After carefully analyzing incriminating evidence, the jury found McVeigh guilty murder and sentenced McVeigh to death; on June 11, 2001, Gulf War veteran Timothy McVeigh was executed by lethal injection. After the verdict was delivered, jury foreman Jim Osgood stated, "I think we can all sleep better at night, knowing the system does work." A good criminal just...

  • Word Count: 1639
  • Approx Pages: 7
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

4. Employment Law - EEOC

Some of the advantages to these methods include cost effectiveness and time and effort saving measures. ... Some of the advantages to these methods include cost effectiveness and time and effort saving measures. ... The trial entails all the information/evidence be presented to the jury. ... Jury trials of this nature can take up to three weeks to conclude. ... Although this system appears to be an arduous process, the system is very effective and worthwhile and assures fair and equal rights to all people. ...

  • Word Count: 1218
  • Approx Pages: 5
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: High School

5. Plea

Although most states had established a system of public prosecution by 1789, the public prosecutor was primarily considered to be acting as a part of the judicial process.[45] The framers of the Constitution laid the foundations of an adversarial justice system in the new republic,[46] but the operation of that system differed significantly from today's system. "Not much is known about the day-to-day work of the courtroom in . . . 1800";[47] however, the absence of certain features in the system can be deduced from the adoption of those features through statute or case law.[48] During...

  • Word Count: 4220
  • Approx Pages: 17

6. Racial Profileing

Despite these facts, the development of the legal system with regard to race seems to have become stagnant. ... There are several levels within the system at which discrimination could occur. The initial contact which anyone has with the justice system is with the police. The police are the institution which serve as a gateway to the legal system, and thus it is only logical to look here first. ... So other aspects of the criminal justice system must be examined. ...

  • Word Count: 3584
  • Approx Pages: 14
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

7. Death Penalty

Questions on whether or not our justice system is capable of sentencing a person to death on accurate evidence. ... Not on whether the death penalty is appropriate or not, that is for a jury of 12 men and women to decide. ... This is an example that the system does work, and that it can correct itself. ... We should not let them predetermine our system of justice. We are the source of what is great about this country and if a jury of us feels that someone is guilty and that their punishment should be death then let it be. ...

  • Word Count: 1444
  • Approx Pages: 6
  • Grade Level: High School

8. Criminals and Mandatory Minimum Sentences

Mandatory minimum sentences (MMS) of imprisonment have been a feature of the Canadian criminal justice system since 1892 when the first Criminal Code was enacted. ... The cost effectiveness of mandatory minimum sentences is a concern to our country and taxpayers. ... " When other factors are not being considered in the sentencing process, it eliminates the cost effectiveness due to every crime being punished the same way even if not proportionate to the offence. With jury trials, there is little incentive for the offender to plead guilty because their individualistic factors are not bein...

  • Word Count: 2147
  • Approx Pages: 9
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

9. Comparison Of Three Articles

The main objective of restorative justice is to provide an alternative to the typical juvenile justice system as well as turning these behavioral, drug or alcohol related incidents into "learning experiences". ... Summary of Article # 3 Juvenile Boot Camps: A Descriptive Analysis of Program Diversity and Effectiveness This article is about juvenile boot camps. ... Students are made completely aware that incidents being handled in the school system can be only so serious. ... The questions posed by the jury may play a very important role in changing the future of delinquent chi...

  • Word Count: 2156
  • Approx Pages: 9

Got a writing question? Ask our professional writer!
Submit My Question