After reading Mark Edmundson's piece, "On the Uses of a Liberal Education," I have arrived at the conclusion that he is somewhat of an extremist. Although he makes many valid points and states them in a most erudite manner, he crosses what I consider to be a fine line between making a valid point and extending that point to an extreme from which there seems to be no return.
Right off the bat, Edmundson gives away some of his inner feelings about his students and give us a peak into his extremist mentality. He begins to make his point about commercialization of universities by describing a situation in which "[the students] are toiling away like the devil's auditors" (Edmundson, 96). Mr. Edmundson continues to make his point by calling the students "informed consumers" (Edmundson, 96), and inferring that they are acting exactly like consumers in a natural economy. Although this inference has some validity to it, I most certainly disagree with it, and will attempt to explain why I feel this way.
Edmundson complains that the students do not really pay attention in class and are interested only in the " affability and the one-liners- (Edmundson, 97). This assumption is based solely on interpretation of the student's reactions to the lecture or discussion given in class. It is quite obvious that here, Edmundson lets his personal feelings cloud his judgment since he personally thinks that these students are ungrateful for the knowledge that they have received. Edmundson bases his judgment on his observations of the reactions coming from his students. He takes the reactions of one or two people and 1) interprets them in a negative manner (such as a yawn taken to be extremely offensive) and 2) exaggerates their offense and makes it out to be like the whole class is mocking him. Furthermore, it would be most gullible to imply that students are, for the most part, lazy and lack the ability to pay attention in class; if this were truly the case, they would not be able to maintain good grades in school.
Was it the Liberals who won the 1906 elections or was it the conservatives who lost it? ... The Liberals won 400 seats out of the 670, and had 49% of the vote. ... The Conservatives under Balfour introduced the Education act in 1902. ... This angered non-conformists as they were paying for religious education that they didn't want. ... The liberals could capitalise and unite people's beliefs on free trade. ...
Liberal reform 1906-1914 The huge scale of the Liberal party's victory in the 1906 general election guaranteed many new faces among the ranks of Liberal MPs, in favour of change in the field of social welfare. ... To solve this problem the government introduced the Education Act of 1906. ... By 1911, less than a third of all education authorities were using rates to support school meal provision and it had taken until 1914 for the Board of Education to make such provision compulsory. Meanwhile, in 1907, the Education Act made medical inspections for children compulsory. ... This Act...
The purpose of a liberal arts education is not to train someone for a position. ... Among the students who are rationally motivated, their love and passion for their potential careers and goals in life are divorced by the standards of a liberal education where forced, accidental, and blind themes prevail. ... It is not a useful process of learning without reference to theories and problems in a choice of one's major and I mean destructive in that Liberal education does not affirm intellectual growth nor provide the personal profit or self worship. Authorities are directing the focus of e...
Liberal Economic Policy The Liberal Party has used a very unique economic policy over the past years that the party has been in office for. ... Issues such as taking money from education, the gun registry, the Kyoto Protocol, and not dropping the GST are a few examples of how the Liberals have wasted the Canadian tax dollars. ... Despite this promise, the liberals have still managed to do this. ... The Liberals have done a fantastic job in cutting taxes. ... this was a bad decision by the Liberal government because the deep cuts in education funding are havi...
"Which is better for students, liberal arts education or vocational education?... I strongly argue that college students must receive liberal arts education for three reasons. ... A liberal arts education helps people to prepare for these roles they will face in the future. ... Finally, liberal arts education is also economically beneficial for students. ... For these reasons, I think that people should receive liberal arts education in colleges. ...
Students that attend a liberal arts college or university receive a well-rounded education. ... A person with a liberal arts education has a much greater advantage over a person that does not. ... A liberal arts education, not only helps socially, but mentally as well. A liberal arts education makes one wise, and all people can benefit from wisdom. ... Overall, a liberal arts education is better then a focused, specialized education. ...
Hence, the liberal party was not genuinely a party of social reforms. ... As these parties could attract voters from the working class, the Liberals had to come out with a more substantial and attractive offer which were the social reforms that not only covered unemployment and old pensions, but also health and education. ... This is evident with the passing of the Education Act (Provision of Meals) in 1906, which gave local council powers to provide free school meals for the students. ... The other act introduced for the schooling children under the Education Act as well was the Medical Inspe...
Conservatives, Liberals, and Feminists all have their views on why the breakdown of the families is occurring. ... The loss of manual labor jobs has had a serious impact on men without a college education and their ability to support a family. ... What worries most liberals is that si! ... The feminist view has several common elements with both the conservatives and the liberals. ... Society needs to invest in better education for parents and quality and affordable child care. ...
A liberal can be whatever he/she wants to be, but also following the guidelines above. ... Lastly Infrastructure - the government's last role is to provide for example roads/buildings, money, public education, and Internet. ... Therefore a classical liberal would believe that the U.S. government in defense of its citizenry is justified in its retaliatory attacks against Afghanistan. A classical liberal would explain the U.S. invading Afghanistan, after the 09/11 attacks, is breaking the harm principle that was written by John Stuart Mill, which is a principle liberals highly respect and ...
