1. Capital Punishment and the Risk of Executing the Inocent
... a punishment. Sorrel's idea of a responsible agent is irrational, and therefore should not be considered. Sarte argues that Capital punishment is not a rationally defensible punishment and that a major reason for its rational indefensibility is that there is no way to insure that the death penalty is not imposed either by mistake or in cases where a more complete knowledge of the situation would ... lead us to consider the punishment to have been undeserved (77). Satre's argument is based on the idea of a rational punishment. He suggests that for a punishment to be rational, a rational ...
- Word Count: 2800
- Approx Pages: 11
- Has Bibliography
- Grade Level: Undergraduate