(855) 4-ESSAYS

Type a new keyword(s) and press Enter to search

Billig's Evaluation of Intergroup Conflict

            
             Billig has evaluated Tajfel and Turner's theorising of intergroup conflict as limited because of the emphasis placed on cognitive processes. Discuss Billig's evaluation and assess his arguments for a discursive psychological approach.
             Response.
             Michael Billig was a student of Henri Tajfel and was originally involved in research to highlight a cognitive approach to intergroup conflict. His research in this area has lead him to a discursive psychological position arguing that the cognitive social approach is limiting in relation to categorisation and does not go far enough in its explanations of extreme prejudice and bigotry. Whilst paying tribute to Tajfel and Turner's paper on cognitive aspects of conflict (1979 cited in Brown 2007) Billig (2002 cited in Brown 2007) suggests that categories cannot be explained in terms of cognitive psychological theories as we actively construct meanings using the language that happens between us and around us thus making categories flexible and dynamic and open to change.
             In order to assess Billig's evaluation and critique of social identity theory it is important to understand exactly what Tajfel and Turner proposed as one of the most influential theories in modern European social psychology on group identity and conflict. This essay will put forward Tajfel and Turner's social identity theory giving their arguments for a cognitive social theory and how it originated. Discussion will then look at Billig's (2002 cited in Brown 2007) critique of the theory and his suggestions to improve it by looking at group conflict and identity from a discursive psychological point of view which would incorporate extreme motivational prejudice and bigotry which he feels is omitted in the cognitive social approach.
             Tajfel and Turner's social identity theory was set against the backdrop of post war Europe where theorists such as Asch (1954 cited in Brown 2007) argued that groups were a negative force which affected otherwise rational individual behaviour which ultimately lead to conflict.


Essays Related to Billig's Evaluation of Intergroup Conflict

1. Stereotyping, Prejudice and Discrimination

Prejudice being a learned attitude, is partly based on the evaluative implication of stereotypic beliefs. ... In the context of social behavior, prejudice can create intergroup conflict, social categorization, and social inequities. Intergroup conflict leads to competition between people. Psychologists" explain this using the "realistic group conflict theory". ... Prejudice within an organization can be a source of friction and conflict. ...

  • Word Count: 842
  • Approx Pages: 3
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

2. Social Influence And Leadership

While we were trying to work on intergroup skills, leadership styles became apparent. ... Conflict Management Conflict management involves the control, but not resolution, of a long-term or deep-rooted conflict. ... In this case, a conflict can be managed to make it more constructive and less destructive thus making the results of the ongoing conflict more beneficial and less damaging to all sides. While conflict is perceived to be destructive within groups, it can also be constructive. Teams, organizations and individuals need conflict to grow. ...

  • Word Count: 2173
  • Approx Pages: 9
  • Grade Level: High School

3. Dispute Resolution

This plan will evaluate conflict as a part of organization, the outcome of the conflict and how to manage conflict. ... Interpersonal conflict 2. Intergroup conflict 3. Interorganizational conflict There are many strategies available for dealing with conflict. ... We wanted to transform A-Type conflict into C-type conflict. ...

  • Word Count: 825
  • Approx Pages: 3
  • Grade Level: High School

4. The Gaza War: Israeli-Palestinian Crisis

The Gaza Israel latest crisis is part of a broad and wide intractable conflict existed since 1948 between Palestinians and Israel over land, resources and identity. ... I would like to use these four theories and try to explain the events through them: The Threat Narrative, The Appraisal Theory, The Frustration Aggression and The Intergroup Emotions. ... This event has created very strong intergroup emotions among Palestinians, both inside Israel and throughout the West Bank towns and villages. ...

  • Word Count: 2340
  • Approx Pages: 9
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

5. Multicultural Education

The conception of multicultural education has been developing in schools since the 1940s and 1950s, but "the 1960s and 1970s brought rapid change to intergroup relations and their relationship with education- (La Belle, 1994 p. 17 & 21). This era brought about a change in education from teaching intergroup relationships "the concept that every student should be taught how to be a part of the integrated society "to the inclusion of concepts of other ethnic groups into the curriculum; this was the start of multiethnic education. ...

  • Word Count: 2168
  • Approx Pages: 9
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

6. Conflict

Since the way one deals with conflict within the relationship will affect how the relationship progresses, it is vital that one posse all the necessary skills to resolve conflict in a way that brings satisfaction to everyone involved. Dewey's steps provide a clear outline of exactly what needs to be addressed when dealing with conflict. ... Establish criteria for evaluating solutions. ... Evaluate solutions. ... This causes little change in their budgets and satisfies their criteria for evaluating solutions. 6. ...

  • Word Count: 1013
  • Approx Pages: 4
  • Grade Level: High School

7. Bruce Tuckman's Theory of Group Development

(Tuckman and Jenson 1977) Conflict can arise and many groups don't move on from this stage. ... His results differentiated from Tuckman's model, in the forming stage intergroup conflict is very much present in Tuckman's hypothesis whereas in Lucoursier's findings there was a lack of conflict between the actual members of the student nurses. ... The group leader should ensure that there is time for the group to celebrate the success of the project and capture best practices for future use and if it was not a successful project - to evaluate what happened and capture lesso...

  • Word Count: 1852
  • Approx Pages: 7
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: High School

8. Development Of Proposed School-linked Services

Another example of a way to facilitate the team forming process is outlined in the handout The Implications of Intergroup Contact Theory for Interprofessional Development. In the section discussing the Intergroup Contact Theory, it states the importance of ensuring that team membership is voluntary. ...

  • Word Count: 737
  • Approx Pages: 3
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

9. Importance of Organizational Behavior

Typical managerial activities include motivating their employees to work harder, ensuring that their jobs are properly designed, resolving conflicts, evaluating their performance, and helping them set their goals to achieve rewards. ... Understanding attitudinal processes, individual differences, group dynamics, intergroup dynamics, organization culture, and power and political behavior can help managers handle such interactions more effectively. ... Performance evaluation, reward systems, and motivation are all aspect...

  • Word Count: 1573
  • Approx Pages: 6
  • Has Bibliography
  • Grade Level: Undergraduate

Got a writing question? Ask our professional writer!
Submit My Question