1. God
... the third is an argument about the possibility of duplication of persons. The first argument says that immaterial and thus unobservable souls can have nothing to do with establishing personal identity. Personal identity does not consist in sameness of soul, for if it did, we would never kn ow who we are or who others are. Since souls are not observable, no ... of the soul), I nevertheless would hold both to be coherent. As noted above, however, Geach argues strongly that only temporary disembodiment is coherent; what alone makes the problem of personal identity manageable a s regards a ...
- Word Count: 10695
- Approx Pages: 43
- Grade Level: High School